Russia’s favorite investment
The tangle of President Donald Trump’s Russia connections is long and complicated, but the evidence all points in the same direction: Trump has been fundamentally corrupted by Russian money and influence. Consider the comments from Richard Dearlove, the former head of Britain’s Secret Intelligence Service, known as MI6: “What lingers for Trump may be what deals—on what terms—he did after the financial crisis of 2008 to borrow Russian money when others in the west apparently would not lend to him.”
Trump was not always reflexively pro-Russia, and the roots of his embrace of Moscow are relatively recent. And, like throughout so much of his business career, Trump’s interest in Russia likely grew from financial desperation. As Fortune Magazine notes, during the 1990s, Trump found himself more than $4 billion in debt to more than 70 banks, and a series of bankruptcies, heavy financial losses, and debt restructuring lead almost all major American banks to simply refuse to do business with him. Consequently, beginning in the 2000s, he began to rely very heavily on foreign banks for his lending, and Russia—with its inner circle of wealthy oligarchs close to President Vladimir Putin and lax financial integrity laws—must have seemed like a cash cow to Trump.
As reported in Slate, on at least five separate occasions, Trump has attempted to launch large projects in Russia, including hotels, spas, and apartment buildings. Both Trump and his son Donald Trump Jr. have made several trips to Moscow in efforts to ingratiate themselves. After one such trip, the senior Trump boasted that “Almost all of the oligarchs were in the room” for one of his meetings. Yet all of these attempts to launch major developments in Russia fizzled, and Donald Jr., who traveled to Moscow six times in one 18-month period alone, was left to observe of the Russian business environment: “It is a question of who knows who, whose brother is paying off who.”
While Trump’s attempts to develop projects in Russia did not pan out, Russians did become an important wellspring for his financial backing. In essence, Trump was not able to invest in Russia; rather, dark Russian money began investing in him. Trump has tried to deflect criticism of his deep Russian ties, once tweeting, “I have ZERO investments in Russia.” But Trump has steadfastly refused to release his taxes or other verifiable information that would detail the level of Russian-linked investment in him and his companies.
Time observed, “The truth, as several columnists and reporters have painstakingly shown since the first hack of a Clinton-affiliated group took place in late May or early June, is that several of Trump’s businesses outside of Russia are entangled with Russian financiers inside Putin’s circle.” The article went on to note, “[I]t is Trump’s financing from Russian satellite business interests that would seem to explain his pro-Putin sympathies.”
It is also worth noting that the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) imposed a $10 million civil money penalty against Trump Taj Mahal Casino Resort for willful and repeated violations of the Bank Secrecy Act. It was the largest penalty FinCEN has ever imposed. It remains unclear if any of these improperly tracked transactions at the casino were linked to Russians or other Putin associates or confidantes.
Historian Francis Fukuyama contemplated the reasons behind Trump never having “uttered a critical word about Putin,” asserting that Putin had hidden leverage “in the form of debts to Russian sources that keep his business empire afloat.” And, certainly, Trump’s scramble for Russian money has entangled him with a web of murky figures and questionable associations, all of which seem to invariably link back to Putin and the Kremlin.
Trump’s presidency has been marred from the start by Russia scandals that underscore how profound his conflicts have become. Michael Flynn was dismissed as national security adviser after it came out that he had given what he described as “incomplete information” to the FBI and Vice President Mike Pence about his contacts and conversations with the Russian ambassador to the United States. Flynn had also failed to disclose to the U.S. Army, as required by law, and on his financial disclosure forms payments he received from the Russian propaganda outlet RT, formerly Russia Today. Flynn appears to be the focus of an ongoing probe by the U.S. Department of Justice for his Russia and other foreign ties. The retired general has invoked the Fifth Amendment in an attempt to avoid appearing under oath before Congress to defend his actions. Trump’s former campaign manager Paul Manafort also appears to be the subject of multiple investigations for his links to Russia during the campaign, as well as for his highly unusual accounting practices and links to bank accounts in locations such as Cyprus, which has long been a favorite for Russian money laundering operations. Manafort has denied wrongdoing in these instances.
During the transition, Jared Kushner, the president’s son-in-law and White House senior adviser, met with Sergey N. Gorkov, chief of Vnesheconombank (VEB), in what the White House described as part of routine diplomatic encounters. Gorkov’s bank has been used as a frequent cover for Russian intelligence service operatives, including one who actively tried to recruit Carter Page, one of Trump’s very first foreign policy advisers during the campaign. Page has given conflicting comments on his alleged Russia links. Gorkov indicated that he met with Kushner in Kushner’s capacity as the chief executive of Kushner Companies, rather than as a transition official. The White House has insisted that this was not the case. However, it is striking that the line between Kushner’s official duties and his business interests was so poorly defined that two participants in the same meeting couldn’t even agree under what capacity Kushner was taking part in these discussions.
Vnesheconombank cropped up again as a key source of finance for another Trump project, this one in Canada. As The Wall Street Journal noted, “VEB, a Russian state-run bank under scrutiny by U.S. investigators, financed a deal involving Donald Trump’s onetime partner in a Toronto hotel tower at a key moment for the project.” The Hill added, “Federal investigators are looking into Trump and his associates’ ties with Russian financial institutions, including VEB, which is currently under Ukraine-related sanctions.”
In May, Trump shocked the nation when he summarily dismissed FBI Director James Comey. When pressed in an interview as to why he had made such a precipitous move, Trump said it was because of “this Russia thing”—a move that a wide variety of legal scholars suggest amounts to a very clear, and perhaps impeachable, case of obstruction of justice.
In an effort to quiet the firestorm, Trump had his law firm issue a certified letter maintaining that, with a few exceptions, Trump’s tax returns—which he has steadfastly refused to release to the public—showed no income of any type from Russian sources. The letter went on to note that a Russian billionaire paid Trump $95 million for a Florida property, more than twice what Trump had paid for it several years previously. In addition, a wide array of experts quickly pointed out how full of holes these claims are in reality. The lawyers’ letter was very carefully worded, and it seems obvious that money from Russia could have easily flowed to Trump from banks in third countries or through arrangements with shell companies. In short, nothing Trump has said or done to date has allowed the public enough information to accurately judge the full extent of his financial ties with Russia, and there is likely a good reason that Trump has tried to keep them secret.
Trump’s conflicts with Russia are profound and remain at the center of a sprawling FBI and intelligence community investigation into Russian interference in the U.S. political system. Time and time again on issues such as Syria and Ukraine, Trump has adopted a policy line that is almost identical to that of Putin. Trump also leaked highly classified information to the Russian foreign minister and ambassador to Washington in a White House meeting, potentially badly damaging the U.S. intelligence relationship with Israel, which provided the intelligence in the first place. As the Daily Beast observed, “We don’t know—yet—why Trump feels the need to cower before Russia. We do know that he’s sold out our allies to benefit an adversary.” Trump’s Russia conflicts are at the heart of a cancer that may well consume his presidency.
Read the full series of columns here.
John Norris is a senior fellow at the Center for American Progress. Carolyn Kenney is a policy analyst with the National Security and International Policy team at the Center.