TUNE IN: Taking Action on AI Today and in the Future

RSVP to join our online audience

Center for American Progress

The Trump Budget: Harming New Yorkers in Appalachia

The Trump Budget: Harming New Yorkers in Appalachia

President Trump’s proposal to dissolve the Appalachian Regional Commission would cost New York millions of dollars and hundreds of jobs.

Part of a Series
A pedestrian crosses the main street of a New York town on November 3, 2016. (AP/Mike Groll)
A pedestrian crosses the main street of a New York town on November 3, 2016. (AP/Mike Groll)

Despite President Donald Trump’s promises to support Appalachian and coal country workers, his budget would completely cut the Appalachian Regional Commission, or ARC—a partnership that works with state and local governments to invest in the region’s workers, businesses, and critical infrastructure. In Appalachian New York, ARC funds support an average of 332 jobs and $10.7 million in earnings every year.

The commission covers the Appalachian region, spanning 420 counties and 13 states, and garners strong bipartisan support. The ARC acts as a catalyst for targeted efforts developed by local communities for local communities, ranging from access to water and internet and the development of agritourism to the preservation of Appalachian history and culture, as well as job creation and entrepreneurship.

One of the core ARC projects is the Appalachian Development Highway System, which seeks to connect Appalachian communities, bring in new jobs, and promote economic development in the region. The system is 89 percent complete. If finished, it is predicted to result in 80,500 jobs, $5.0 billion in increased value-added production, and $3.2 billion in increased wages for workers in Appalachia by 2035—a return of $3 for every dollar invested.

The ARC empowers local governments to design and implement economic revitalization plans that address the needs of their communities. From 2007 to 2013, ARC nonhighway investments accounted for nearly 10,000 jobs and $400 million in regional earnings, and since its founding, these nonhighway investments have brought an estimated 311,835 jobs to Appalachia. In ARC counties from 1969 to 2012, job growth was 4.2 percent higher and income growth was 5.5 percent higher on average compared to neighboring non-ARC counties.

Appalachian voters trusted President Trump to understand their needs and create good jobs—95 percent of the counties covered by the Appalachian Regional Commission voted for him in 2016. But Trump is already turning his back on Appalachia.

Impact of the Appalachian Regional Commission in New York

The ARC covers 14 counties in New York and an estimated 1 million residents. Thirteen of the 14 counties covered by the ARC—93 percent—voted for Trump in 2016. These counties fall into three congressional districts—the 19th, 22nd, and 23rd Districts—which are represented by Rep. John Faso (R), Rep. Claudia Tenney (R), and Rep. Tom Reed (R).

Without the ARC, New Yorkers would lose out on an average of 332 jobs and $10.7 million in added earnings every year. Here is the breakdown:

  • Since its founding, the ARC has brought more than 16,200 jobs, invested $192.4 million, and led to $526.2 million in increased earnings for New Yorkers.
  • From October 2015 to January 2017, the ARC invested more than $2.3 million in 18 projects in New York, which attracted an additional $750,000 in private investment. These projects provided training and education for more than 100 students and workers and built up New York’s critical broadband, transportation, and water infrastructure systems.
  • With ARC support, Alfred State College launched a new Advanced Manufacturing Center, which will prepare 50 students each year to equip students for careers in renewable energy.


At the ballot box, voters in Appalachia trusted Donald Trump to fight for their jobs and their communities as president. Cutting the ARC is an outright betrayal of Appalachian communities and would leave them without the funds to implement critical workforce, education, and infrastructure projects.

Sunny Frothingham is a Senior Researcher at the Center for American Progress.

The positions of American Progress, and our policy experts, are independent, and the findings and conclusions presented are those of American Progress alone. A full list of supporters is available here. American Progress would like to acknowledge the many generous supporters who make our work possible.


Sunny Frothingham

Senior Researcher

Explore The Series