Read the report
With electricity demand skyrocketing, the United States faces the need to expand and modernize its grid at an unprecedented rate over the coming decade. However, the nation lacks a strong industrial base for many of the components required to do so, meeting current demand largely through imports. The Center for American Progress proposes that the United States launch a strategic build-out of the domestic industrial base, making investments to manufacture the components necessary to meet the needs of the grid today and far into the future.
Critical areas for investment
To meet surging demand for electricity and grid construction, the United States must invest in producing the grid’s key components and their inputs, products for which the United States is currently heavily reliant on imports. Here, transformers and high-voltage direct current (HVDC) technology emerge as the most important to onshore.
Transformers
Transformers are critical connection points on the grid, responsible for increasing and decreasing voltage as electricity moves from generators to end users.
- Grain-oriented electrical steel (GOES): A critical input into transformer cores, making up 25 percent of a transformer’s cost, GOES is currently produced by only one manufacturer in the United States, and the country faces an import reliance around 90 percent for high-grade GOES.
- Large power transformers (LPTs): Specialized large transformers needed to handle large loads and long-distance transmission. Approximately 90 percent of all electricity consumed in the United States flows through at least one LPT; however, more than 80 percent of LPTs are imported, and order lead times can measure up to a year.
High-voltage direct current
This technology is suitable for moving large amounts of power over vast distances.
- Power electronics: Alternatives to conventional transformers, power electronics enable the digital monitoring and control of the grid as well as the integration of renewables and HVDC technology. At the core of power electronics are power semiconductors. While the United States has led the research and development of advanced power semiconductor technologies such as silicon carbide transistors, it risks failing to commercialize the technology for HVDC and other grid applications.
- Cable manufacturing: Although cables are critical to all types of transmission, the United States faces high import dependence for both HVDC and conventional alternating current (AC) cables, the former of which can take longer than five years to procure, limiting the build-out of next-generation HVDC systems.
Recommendations
To support the development of a robust grid component supply chain and the construction of an advanced, clean grid that supplies reliable and affordable energy, CAP calls for the federal government to undertake a multifaceted industrial strategy. The policies proposed below comprise a plan to mitigate the bottleneck of available components, put Americans to work, and get electrons flowing.
Rapidly increasing supply
The supply of grid components needs to be rapidly increased in order to meet the moment. To do so, the government should support the rapid expansion of grid component manufacturing by:
- Making large-scale, consistent investment. Utilize grants and production tax credits to support the immediate scale-up of domestic grid component manufacturing.
- Utilizing the Defense Production Act (DPA). Utilize DPA titles I and III to increase domestic production of grid components, as outlined in the Energy Bills Relief Act.
- Expanding the use of the Defense Industrial Base Fund. Clarify the statutory language establishing the Defense Industrial Base Fund to ensure that power grid components qualify for support.
- Standardizing transformer and HVDC design and equipment. Led by the U.S. Department of Energy, the federal government should facilitate the setting of uniform standards for HVDC equipment and transformers to speed production and deployment.
Backstopping demand
Historically, demand for grid components has been hard to predict and lacked long-term demand assurance, making investing in building out manufacturing capacity a risk for manufacturers. The federal government should intervene to ensure that there is adequate and stable demand to support the industry.
- Create demand certainty through government long-term procurement guarantees, created via a virtual reserve where the government becomes the buyer of last resort, and/or the creation of a new government entity to finance, build, and operate a national HVDC network.
- To subsidize production costs, Congress should consider increasing the 45X credit for inverters and primary aluminum. In addition, the credit should be expanded to include LPTs, GOES, and HVDC components.
- Utilize sections 232 of the Trade Expansion Act of 1962 and 301 of the Trade Act of 1974 for grid components and materials to protect domestic industry when necessary and overcome unfair foreign trade practices.
Addressing material shortages
- Raw materials strategy: Utilize government grants to support primary aluminum and GOES production, provided an appropriate level of supply is guaranteed for grid component production.
- Circularity: Ensure that grid components are refurbished and recycled at the end of their useful life to minimize raw material demand and associated environmental and community impacts.
Supporting a high-quality workforce
The United States faces a significant workforce shortage even to maintain the current grid, with massive expansion needed to build the grid of the future. The federal government should support the development of the needed grid workforce through:
- Union neutrality. Government support for grid component manufacturers should require union neutrality.
- Workforce development and training. The federal government should support registered apprenticeships, preapprenticeships, and other joint labor-management training programs for workers in the grid components industry.
Data collection, future planning, and coordination
Federal data on grid component production and deployment is incomplete and often out of date. Industrial policy cannot solve problems of which it is unaware, nor can its efficacy be assessed without data. To address the lack of sufficient data on grid component production and deployment, CAP proposes that a multiagency study and review process be launched to examine and report on:
- Examine domestic needs and production. Conduct a comprehensive review of current domestic production capacity as well as a five-year look-ahead. This would include a review of current LPT deployments and other transformers critical to the grid.
- Report on trade flows. Analyze global trade flows for grid components and their inputs to identify any associated vulnerabilities or excessive dependencies.
- Conduct an authority analysis. Review existing federal authorities to identify future opportunities to support the domestic production of grid components.