Center for American Progress

RELEASE: CAP Proposes Ending Insurer Prior Authorization as Patients Face Widespread Delays and Denials
Press Release

RELEASE: CAP Proposes Ending Insurer Prior Authorization as Patients Face Widespread Delays and Denials

Washington, D.C. — A new policy proposal from the Center for American Progress would ban prior authorization by health insurance companies, removing insurers from medical decision-making and replacing their approval processes with independent clinical review for costly, overused services. 

Three in 10 insured adults report that their insurer has denied or delayed care in the past two years. Among cancer patients who have experienced prior authorization, 69 percent reported delays in care, with one-third of those patients waiting at least a month. More than one-quarter of physicians say that prior authorization has caused a serious adverse event, including hospitalization, disability, or death of a patient.

“Americans are paying more for health insurance and having to fight even harder to get the care they need,” said Topher Spiro, senior fellow at CAP and co-author of the proposal. “We can do better than a health care system that demands patients and their families navigate corporate red tape just to be treated. Congress can take insurers out of medical decision-making and establish an independent process that actually puts patients’ health first.”

Under CAP’s proposal:

  • Routine care would no longer require advance approval. Primary care, chronic disease management, preventive services, and generic drugs would be exempt from review. 
  • Independent clinicians would review costly, overused services instead of insurers. Insurers would pay an accredited organization that has no ties to an insurer or to a pharmacy benefit manager. Payment would be a flat monthly fee per enrollee, with no financial reward for denying care.
  • Reviewers would follow one transparent set of evidence-based standards. Patients and providers would receive decisions within 48 hours. Qualified clinical professionals would conduct reviews, and a human would make any final denial decision.
  • Providers who repeatedly order inappropriate care would be given the opportunity to change behavior and would face lower payments if problems persist. Independent reviewers could examine paid claims for patterns of overuse, but patients would not face additional costs from those findings.
  • Doctors would get guidance when ordering care. Electronic health records would include prompts based on the same clinical standards, helping providers choose appropriate treatment before a review becomes necessary.

The proposal builds on CAP’s Patients’ Bill of Rights to curb excessive premium increases, lower deductibles by limiting high hospital prices, and restrain insurer profits and administrative costs.

Read the analysis: “Ending Health Insurance Denials: A Path to Timely, Evidence-Based Care” by Topher Spiro and Brian Keyser

For more information on this topic or to speak with an expert, please contact Christian Unkenholz at [email protected]

Default Opt Ins

Variable Opt Ins

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.