Washington, D.C. — A new report from the Center for American Progress, authored by former Biden administration officials, offers an inside look on lessons learned from implementing the climate and clean energy grant and loan programs of the historic Inflation Reduction Act.
The report, drawing on interviews with more than 65 former Biden administration officials and career civil servants, discusses what went right, where implementers encountered barriers, where changes in process or policy could have helped accelerate delivery, and where entirely new approaches should be taken.
The report also includes a foreword from John Podesta, chair of the board at CAP and former senior advisor to President Joe Biden for clean energy innovation and implementation. Podesta offers some personal observations, based on his White House experiences, and offers specific recommendations for lawmakers and agency officials on how best to put the country back on the right path to building a clean economy that directly and tangibly delivers for the American people.
The Inflation Reduction Act was the largest-ever U.S. investment in clean energy, creating hundreds of thousands of jobs and including more than $120 billion in new grant programs. Although the Trump administration and congressional Republicans repealed most of the measure’s provisions, there are valuable lessons to learn from the experience that can inform future legislation, executive branch staffing and structure, and investments from external stakeholders.
Among the report’s findings:
- Clear goals and flexibility in the statute sped up implementation. Implementation was most successful when congressional intent was clear, agencies clearly and consistently articulated desired program outcomes, and Congress granted agencies sufficient discretion and flexibility to design how programs would be implemented.
- Unnecessary complexity slowed implementation. Statutory language resulting in multiple, fragmented, and overlapping programs, combined with executive branch decisions to add further requirements, created overly prescriptive or complex new programs.
- Hiring quickly and effectively is critical. Every agency struggled to navigate arcane human resources policies and processes that made it difficult to quickly hire or internally transfer the necessary staff to design and implement large and highly complex programs.
- Speed, durability, and policy complexity are competing priorities. There are real trade-offs between speed, durability, and different policy priorities when it comes to designing grant and loan programs. Each additional policy priority layered into a program increases its complexity and implementation timeline—both during initial design and competition and later during project delivery.
- External support needs to start earlier. Philanthropies and external stakeholders played a critical role in supporting prospective grantees, particularly low-income and underserved grantees. In many cases, this support did not scale until late in the application period or even after awards were made.
- Significant, effective communications support is critical. The Biden administration struggled to effectively communicate the benefits of the Inflation Reduction Act. Despite a significant emphasis on storytelling by the president and Cabinet that resulted in hundreds of local “Investing in America”-branded events, there was limited impact on public perception, and efforts to promote the programs were not effective at breaking through the political noise.
Read the report: “Lessons From Implementing the Inflation Reduction Act” by Emily McAuliffe, Kristina Costa, Whitney Muse, Zealan Hoover, Sarah Greenberger, and Arjun Krishnaswami
For more information or to speak with an expert, please contact Sam Hananel at [email protected].