Universal 401(k)
Ensure That People Can Retire With Dignity by Reaping the Benefits of Their Lifelong Work
Our current system for encouraging savings is woefully inadequate. High-income earners are triple winners. First, they are the most likely to have employer-provided 401(k)s with generous company matches. Second, because many have business income, they have access to other tax-deferred savings options, like SEP IRAs. Third, and most importantly, being in the 35 percent tax bracket gives them $0.35 in tax benefits for every $1.00 they put away. In contrast, low-income earners are the least likely to have an employer plan and if they pay no income taxes they get no incentive from retirement savings deductions.
At the same time, our system is as full of holes as Swiss cheese: half of working families lack an employer-provided retirement plan in any given year. Amongst families closest to retirement (those 55-59), half have $10,000 or less in an IRA or 401(k). This has had a sizable impact on the economy: our private savings rate has plummeted from 2.3 percent in 2000 to -1.8 percent in the third quarter of last year—the lowest since the Great Depression.
The Plan:
1. Create a Flat Tax Incentive to encourage savings: provide every American a flat 30 percent refundable credit for retirement savings, regardless of their income.
2. Establish a Universal 401(k) to ensure every American has access to a savings plan, with generous matching funds. Building on the model of the Clinton USA accounts proposal, the Universal 401(k) would provide:
• A $2-to-$1 matching credit for the first $2,000 low-income families save each year;
• A $1-to-$1 match for middle-income families; and
• A $0.50-to-$1 match for those in the upper middle class.
Ideally, workers would be automatically enrolled in new accounts. We should also authorize workers to automatically deposit portions of their EITC or Child Tax Credit refunds directly into these accounts to help low- and moderate-income families build nest eggs.
Find more on these proposals in Gene Sperling’s book “The Pro-Growth Progressive,” Chapter 12, pages 183-206. For a further description of the Universal 401(k) see Sperling’s “A Progressive Framework for Social Security Reform,” Center for American Progress, January 10, 2005 and his New York Times column, “New Ways of Saving,” November 18, 2002. For more on the Flat Tax Incentive, see Sperling’s column, “U.S. Needs Flat Tax Incentive to Spark Savings,” April 19, 2005.
The Expert: Gene Sperling
To contact one of our experts please call/e-mail Sean Gibbons, director of media strategy, at 202-481-8228