National Security Policy Weekly banner
This Week
  • Haiti's Changing Tide, Reuben Brigety and Natalie Ondiak
  • How to Move Forward in Afghanistan, David Barno
  • A View from Israel, Alon Pinkas
Expert Commentary
  • A Sustainable Security Approach to Haiti, Natalie Ondiak
  • Afghanistan A Greater National Security Concern than Iraq, Lawrence Korb
This Week

Reuben Brigety and Natalie Ondiak, "Haiti's Changing Tide: A Sustainable Security Case Study," Center for American Progress, September 1, 2009
The sustainable security paradigm developed by the Center for American Progress provides a useful framework for examining developments in Haiti and rethinking U.S. policy toward the country. Sustainable security is a view of foreign policy that combines national security, collective security, and human security. It argues that the challenges arising from poor development outcomes can present very real threats to American security. As such, the best way to meet such national security threats is to address the core development problems from which they arise, and to do so in a cooperative manner with the host government and the international community. The core of the sustainable security approach is to use the nexus between development and security as both a means of identifying threats to our interests and a method for dealing with them. The complexity of Haiti’s development challenges makes it a highly appropriate candidate for the sustainable security model.

Click here to read the full report.

David Barno, "How to Move Forward in Afghanistan," Middle East Bulletin interview, September 15, 2009
I have been talking about four things in recent weeks that I think essentially have to happen; ... The first is that the U.S. has to defeat the Taliban strategy. ... We have to prove that their outlook on running out the clock won't work. ... Secondly, ... we have to help this next government of Afghanistan restore the trust and credibility between the Afghan government and the people of Afghanistan. ... Third, we need to work hard to get unity of effort at the ground level in Afghanistan ... not just between the military-civil enterprise on the international side, but also between the Afghan government's local officials, Afghan military, Afghan police, and coalition military forces, diplomats and development officials. ... And the last thing may be the most challenging and the one that's most at the forefront of American media reporting today. We collectively—the U.S. and our allies—have got to reframe the narrative for Afghanistan. We have to explain clearly ... what the long-term end game is, what we are trying to accomplish, what the downside risks are of failure are and why this effort absolutely must succeed. We have not done that sufficiently, and the slippage in popular support reflects the lack of clarity in that message.

Click here to read the full interview.

Alon Pinkas, "A View from Israel," Middle East Bulletin interview, September 10, 2009
Question: You are visiting the United States as part of a public policy campaign on behalf of the Israeli government. What are the primary objectives of the campaign?
 Answer: There has been a sense in Israel in the last several months that the U.S. and Israel do not necessarily see eye to eye about a series of issue. Numerous media reports have compounded that by drawing a picture of a seemingly ongoing confrontation. The fundamental idea of this campaign is to talk to as many members of Congress, the media, university faculty and students and Jewish groups and explain to them that while there may be policy differences or emphasis, in general the government of Israel is willing and ready to seriously and expeditiously engage in a peace process and has no doubts whatsoever about doing it in complete cooperation with the U.S. administration.

Click here to read the full interview.


Expert Commentary

Ask the Expert - Natalie Ondiak describes a 'dual window of opportunity' in Haiti: "The physical and security and political space is better than it has been in decades ... Haiti and the United States and the international community can engage together to create real development opportunities. Haiti is at a real serious turning point.

Christian Science Monitor - Lawrence Korb argues that despite recent attacks in Iraq, Afghanistan remains a more pressing national security priority: "I don't think you should forget about [Iraq]. But if you said to me, 'I have a limited number of troops and should I put them in Iraq or Afghanistan?' then I would say Afghanistan."



General Odom

Middle East Bulletin Logo

Enough Campaign Logo


Event Resources


There are no public events for the week of September 16, 2009.

Sign up:
Policy e-newsletters
The Progress Report

To unsubscribe, click here

Support the Center for American Progress

Comments, questions:
Email Us

National Security Policy Weekly is a product of the Center for American Progress
www.americanprogress.org | contact us | unsubscribe