National Security Policy Weekly banner
This Week
  • The Imperfect Election was the Easy Part, Brian Katulis and Hardin Lang
  • Turkey: Strong Relations Built on Shared Interests, Robert Wexler
  • Holder's Decision to Re-Investigate Torture is Correct, Ken Gude
  • Two Years to Self Destruct in Sudan, John Norris
  • Darfur: A Way of Life is Lost, Natalie Ondiak and Omer Ismail
Expert Commentary
  • Financial Assistance to Former Guantanamo Detainees Unlikely, Ken Gude
  • Fraud Claims Threaten Afghan Poll Legitimacy, Brian Katulis
  • Sudan Policy Headed in Wrong Direction, John Prendergast
  • More Precise Afghan Debate Needed, Brian Katulis
  • Afghan Vote Process Still Ongoing, Brian Katulis
This Week

Brian Katulis and Hardin Lang, "The Imperfect Election was the Easy Part," Foreign Policy, September 8, 2009
Holding an imperfect election was the easy part. Yet, no matter who emerges as the ballot's victor, the vote did not magically transform the country. Like Iraq's 2005 elections, the voting process in Afghanistan merely provided some indication of the internal balance of power between those who chose to participate, as well as those who did not, including affiliates of the Taliban. Unfortunately, that balance appears to increasingly favor the latter.

Click here to read the full article.

Robert Wexler, "Turkey: Strong Relations Built on Shared Interests," Middle East Bulletin interview, September 8, 2009
In the past, Turkey had very chaotic and difficult relations with several of its neighbors, particularly Syria. ... So what Turkey has done is change the dynamic in the region and it desires to have strong and good relations with all of its neighbors, even while it may fundamentally disagree with some of the practices and policies of its neighbors. Sometimes that is a controversial policy to pursue. ... However we very much should respect both the effort and the integrity of the policy, because ultimately it advances Turkey’s interests, and in almost all of the cases, it advances America’s strategic interests in the region as well. … By and large, the influence and the persuasive ability of Turkey in the region is enhanced when it pursues policies of engagement and warm relations with its neighbors and I think we should view that kind of development in a very positive light for our own interests.

Click here to read the full interview.

Ken Gude, "Holder's Decision to Re-Investigate Torture is Correct," Center for American Progress Action Fund Wonk Room blog, September 1, 2009
In an op-ed in Saturday’s New York Times, novelist Joseph Finder charged that Attorney General Eric Holder’s decision to appoint career prosecutor John Durham to begin a preliminary investigation into allegations of homicide and torture made by the CIA Inspector General “serves to delegitimize our government.” Finder claims Holder recklessly overturned the conclusion of the Alberto Gonzales-led Justice Department to close the criminal inquiry in a move that “doesn’t look much like justice; it looks like politics.” ... Far from any effort by the attorney general to enforce the law, the failure to investigate those crimes is what would cause further grievous harm to our country.

Click here to read the full article.

John Norris, "Two Years to Self Destruct in Sudan," Foreign Policy
, September 1, 2009
Imagine if we had enjoyed the luxury of knowing, two years before it happened, that Yugoslavia would disintegrate in 1991. Or just think if U.S. diplomats had been able to predict years earlier exactly when the Soviet Union was going to collapse. One certainly hopes the United States would have been better positioned to deal with these momentous events. But a current case gives one pause. Sudan might very well split in half in precisely two years, and policymakers have taken far too little notice.

Click here to read the full article.

Natalie Ondiak and Omer Ismail, "Darfur: A Way of Life is Lost," Forced Migration Review, September 2009
The impact of displacement on Darfuris is especially severe because of the genocidal nature of the violence. It not only affects those millions who are currently displaced but will continue to shape the lives of Darfuris for generations to come. Compared to other protracted displacement situations, the duration of Darfur’s forced migration has been short. However, the fact that Darfuris have ended up in camps means that they are not able to practise the livelihoods that they have been pursuing for generations.

Click here to read the full article.

Expert Commentary

The American Prospect - Ken Gude notes Congressional opposition to resettling Guantanamo detainees in the U.S. makes providing financial assistance to former detainees now living abroad would be challenging: "The process up till now has to provide no support to the detainees themselves but perhaps provide some small assistance to the government taking them in."

KCRW - Brian Katulis analyzes reports of fraud in the Afghan presidential election and their impact on the legitimacy of the government: "I think it's looking sharply more pessimistic, the longer this goes on, and the more stories come out and the more that complaints aren't really dealt with or adjudicated. I think we're reaching a pretty tenuous phase in this election."

Ask the Expert - Enough Project's John Prendergast argues that the Obama administration's Sudan policy is "going in the wrong direction": "We have in Darfur a peace process that has stumbled along for the last few years resulting in no substantial progress toward peace, and the Obama administration just wants to provide more support to that failed process. ... We need to see consequences for nonimplementation."

The Star - Brian Katulis cautions that "if anyone hoped this election would re-legitimize Afghanistan's leaders, the probability has decreased substantially": "What we need is a much more precise debate about the end goals, the challenges and the resources necessary to achieve it. And with American patience appearing to wane, it is necessary sooner, not later."

The Takeaway - Brian Katulis assesses corruption allegations in the Afghan elections: "We don't know yet the magnitude or how large those alleged vote fraud instances are, but it looks pretty serious. ... I think it was way too early the day of the election or the day after the election for the president or anyone else to call this process a success, because it still is a process."



General Odom

SeeProgress Button

Middle East Bulletin Logo

Enough Campaign Logo


Event Resources

Haiti's Changing Tide
September 14, 2009, 10:00 AM - 11:00 AM

Haiti has been plagued by variety of intractable problems throughout its history. External shocks such as the rise in food prices and four hurricanes in 2008 led to widespread devastation. In 2009, the international community has once again started to pay attention to Haiti.

A rare "dual opportunity" exists in Haiti right now. Haiti's physical security is better than it has been in a long time and the United States can rethink its U.S.-Haiti policy. CAP researchers traveled to Haiti in June 2009 to examine Haiti as a sustainable security case study, looking at security and development challenges.

The Center for American Progress is pleased to host Haitian Prime Minister Michèle Pierre-Louis for a discussion about Haiti's future prospects and the release of the report "Haiti's Changing Tide: A Sustainable Security Case Study."

Introductions by:
John Podesta, President and Chief Executive Officer, Center for American Progress
Reuben Brigety, Director, Sustainable Security Program, Center for American Progress

Featured Speaker:
Prime Minister Michèle Pierre-Louis

For more information and to RSVP, please click here.

Sign up:
Policy e-newsletters
The Progress Report

To unsubscribe, click here

Support the Center for American Progress

Comments, questions:
Email Us

National Security Policy Weekly is a product of the Center for American Progress
www.americanprogress.org | contact us | unsubscribe