Center for American Progress Center for American Progress
Issues Domestic Civil Rights, Liberties, and Justice

Friendly Fire: How John Roberts Differs from His Hero and Mentor

Since his nomination to the Supreme Court, John Roberts' supporters have tried to cloak him in the robes of the judge for whom he first clerked: the legendary Henry Friendly of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit. David Leitch, a former Bush deputy counsel and Roberts' law partner, told Newsweek that Roberts speaks of Friendly with "deep reverence" and "a certain twinkle in his eye." Richard Lazarus, Roberts' old roommate and a Democrat who now teaches at Georgetown, has said that Roberts "had deep respect for [Friendly's] intellect and approach to the law." And Stephen Barnett—another former Friendly clerk and deputy solicitor general—predicted that Roberts would drift toward Supreme Court moderate Stephen Breyer "as a conservative case-by-case pragmatist in the common-law mold, like Henry Friendly." Each invocation of the brilliant and principled Republican judge suggests that Roberts could become the same.

Read more here.

This article was originally published in Slate.

To speak with our experts on this topic, please contact:

For print and radio, John Neurohr, Deputy Press Secretary
202.481.8182 or jneurohr@americanprogress.org

For TV, Andrea Purse, Deputy Director of Media Strategy
202.446.8429 or apurse@americanprogress.org

For web, Erin Lindsay, Online Marketing Manager
202.741.6397 or elindsay@americanprogress.org

Subscribe to RSS Feeds

RSS IconSite-Wide and Issue-Specific RSS Feeds

Related Articles

The First Step Toward Closing Guantánamo, by Ken Gude

Not the Right Choice, by Mark Agrast

Talking Points: Roberts and Alito

In Their Own Words: Roberts and Alito

Prosecutors and Politicians, by Mark Agrast

Also by Robert Gordon

More Equity and Less Red Tape, October 14, 2008

Did Liberals Cause the Sub-Prime Crisis?, April 7, 2008

Criminal Intent, March 25, 2008